While The Greatest Showman is a more recent exploration of circus impresario P. T. Barnum’s life, it was Mark Bramble’s Broadway musical Barnum that opened the tent first. This energetic but lopsided revival now makes its way to Canterbury’s Marlowe Theatre as part of its UK tour.

Bramble’s book, with music by Cy Coleman and Michael Stewart’s lyrics, spotlights the ringmaster’s life from his humble beginnings through stardom, touring the States with an impressive, eye-catching array of circus talent in tow, ranging from jugglers and acrobats to extraordinary opera singers and even a giant elephant. Played by Michael Crawford when Barnum made its UK debut in 1981 in the West End, Barnum (played in this touring version by a charismatic Matt Rawle) takes us on a whistlestop tour of his life, along with the significant choices, gambles, and chances he took to make his fortune. Barnum’s life is remarkable and chaotic, largely propped up by his devoted wife Charity (Monique Young), with stints in the circus ring and even being elected mayor of Bridgeport reiterating his larger-than-life character.

Rawle’s Barnum is energetic and engaging, immediately looking at ease whether doing crowd work during the musical’s opening exchanges or treading the high wire himself in one of the musical’s most iconic moments. Obsessed with the concept of ‘humbug’ (the ability to trick and deceive in an entertaining rather than conniving way), Rawle captures Barnum’s cheeky, resilient character, desperate to bring entertainment and make a lot of money at the same time. Though it takes a while for the production to get going, by the musical’s superb finale it is impossible not to get swept up in the exciting big dreams Barnum both has and sells, with a grinning, strutting Rawle rightly seizing the spotlight.

Meanwhile, Young’s loyal but restrained wife Charity serves neatly as the anchor pulling Barnum back down to Earth. There is a neat tenderness in Young’s portrayal, blending an ever-present devotion to her husband with a gentle reservation and slight frustration at his misdemeanours. It is here, though, that the musical pivots away from exploring Barnum’s life and flaws, as his six-month liaison with Swedish singer Jenny Lind (a glorious Penny Ashmore) is quickly swept under the carpet by Charity. This rapid sense of forgiveness feels too forgiving for contemporary audiences, albeit rooted in a true story, and is told in a way that hints at Barnum’s darker ways while skimming over them to keep the ringmaster as the piece’s hero above all else.

Directed by Jonathan O’Boyle, Barnum flies on the relentless sense of spectacle it eventually achieves. Spearheaded by a hard-working trio of leads, the piece is elevated by its brilliant ensemble, who fly, spin, leap, and juggle their way through a huge number of ambitiously choreographed routines by Oti Mabuse that capture the awe of circus acts. It is here, though, that the piece wobbles under its uneven nature.

While spectacles such as Barnum’s effective tightrope scene (caught between his wife and lover), a giant elephant puppet, and Fergus Rattigan’s entertaining cameo as General Tom Thumb are impressive, the first half largely drifts under the weight of relentless exposition where the book has tried to cram too much into the first act. The revelation that Barnum’s first big success, his ‘American Museum’, has burned down is oddly announced and only briefly addressed, with the showman’s sadness quickly replaced by another jaunty number that makes it hard to engage with the struggles he faces getting back on the road to stardom.

It is only in the second half, where the music, book, and Mabuse’s brilliant choreography combine towards a flourishing finale, that the production builds like a circus to a final epic crescendo. Yet it leaves you wondering why it took so long to reach a moment that allows you to sit back and indulge in Barnum’s wonder. The final large ensemble number, ‘Join the Circus’, is superbly delivered under George Dyer’s musical arrangement, reaching a sensational cacophony of sound that almost pulls you out of your seat in a supreme act of musical theatre flamboyance.

At almost fifty years old, there are a few too many moaning wife jokes that show the musical’s age. Yet when these are shed and the piece focuses on what it and Barnum are best at, entertainment, Barnum continues to soar. While not all of it will make you want to run away and join the circus, a superb finale featuring powerful singing, flying acrobats, firing cannons, and waving flags makes up for a few wonky tricks to prove that when let loose, Barnum is still no humbug.

Rating: 3 out of 5.

Check out my other reviews!


Discover more from Read About Stuff | London Theatre Reviews & Culture

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Tags